I wouldn't call myself a fan of Eli's work. Posted February 5, 2012 by Mitchell K
I don’t like Eli Manning. I don’t like Eli Manning at all. Eli Manning just won his second Super Bowl. Eli Manning is now considered a Hall of Famer. I disagree. Here’s why.
I know that Super Bowls are said to be the ultimate judge of a quarterback. Why is Dan Marino held in such high standards after not winning a ring? John Elway would’ve been a lock for Canton before he won his rings at the end of his career. Warren Moon is in the Hall and doesn’t have any hardware. So is Jim Kelly. Trent Dilfer has a ring but won’t be getting close to getting a bronze bust. It is the ultimate stage, but the Super Bowl shouldn’t hold up a quarterback higher or lower than they should be based on what they have done during their entire career.
Up until this season, Eli Manning hasn’t really been that good. He has averaged over one interception per game throughout his career, and even led the league with 25 in 2010. He hasn’t had sustained great play for more than one season. If Eli is going to play like he did this season for a couple more years, then I’ll buy into the Hall of Fame talk. I won’t after one good season which was preceded by seven that were roughly average.
Let’s discuss the two Super Bowls that Eli won. They were both aided by great defenses. I’m not saying that’s a knock on him, but the media is making it seem like he’s been going out and throwing for 350 yards and tossing 5 touchdowns in every big game. The guy comes through in the clutch, but the clutch wouldn’t be there without the two incredible defensive fronts that the Giants have had. The two plays that will be remembered were plays by receivers, one lucky and one great. David Tyree had the luckiest catch since the “Immaculate Reception” that led to the winning touchdown (not to mention that Asante Samuel dropped a sure interception after the Tyree’s catch). The Helmet Catch never should’ve happened. Not because it was lucky, but if the refs would’ve called the play like they should’ve then the ball never would’ve left Eli’s hand. The holding on the play was criminal, and Eli was held up by two of the Pats defensive lineman which usually draws a whistle before the quarterback can take a huge shot while he’s defenseless. Neither thing was called, and the rest is history. One thing I’ll never let go is that Eli threw the ball high and down the middle, nowhere within ten yards of a receiver, and that would’ve and should’ve gotten him verbally abused by his QB coach had the ball not been separated from the helmet by a washed up Rodney Harrison. Now fast forward to Mario Manningham making a picture perfect catch on the sideline in this season’s installment of the New England – New York championship. There is no way that he could’ve done anything else better: catching the ball, getting both feet down, absorbing the hit, and maintaining control throughout the entire play. Granted, this season’s throw was much better than the one in 2007, but two players made that play even though history will remember Eli a lot more than Manningham.
In no way do I think Eli is a bad quarterback. If he keeps playing like he did this season, I’ll actually be glad because that means I get to watch some great football (just as long as he doesn’t do it against the Packers).Do I have an agenda against him right now? Yes. He has failed me in fantasy football and has knocked my team out of the playoffs in two of the last four years. Despite that, I think he can be a Hall of Fame player; I’m just a skeptic right now.
Obviously, the most pain that is being felt as a result of Sandusky's actions are not on the part of the citiens of State College, students of Penn State, fans of the football program, or the family members of anyone in the Penn State athletic department. The most pain that is being felt is that of the victims. I am not qualified to assume what they are feeling, nor could I ever imagine what it would feel like to be subject to such disgusting acts. I just know that, more so than the community of State College, nothing will ever be the same.
Eagles (-2.5) over BILLS – The Eagles can’t protect Michael Vick, and the Bills can’t get to the quarterback. I think this is a perfect matchup for Philly, and they need to win to try and pick up the city even a little bit after the Phillies were eliminated from the postseason.